By now you’ve probably heard about the controversial children’s book Maggie Goes on a Diet. If you haven’t, this bit from Good Morning America will fill you in on both the book and the author’s intent, as well as the popular reaction to it – disgust. Book reviewers and bloggers like myself the world over have been ranting and raving about this book. The bullet points:
It’s aimed at young girls: depending on the seller, ages between 4 and 12 years old. It depicts a young girl, Maggie, who is overweight. She eats a lot and gets picked on. She starts eating healthier and exercising, loses weight, becomes a popular soccer star at school. The book is teaching children to associate the things they believe will make them happy with their weight.
Just reading about the book, not having read it myself, I think it’s awful, too. Why am I not shouting from rooftops about it like everyone else? A few reasons. It is getting advertising you can’t even pay for (for books anyway) and will sell a lot more copies now than it would have. It is the third book penned by this author., but the other two titles, while maybe not so psyche-damaging are on par with the quality of this book. What I mean is…
I write for children. I’m not published (though this is making think about putting more effort into that, let me tell you) and you’ve never seen my name on a spine in Barnes & Noble. I do study the craft and I am a mom who reads many books to her child every single day. I grew up reading wonderful books. To that end, I feel sufficiently experienced in telling you: Even if the message of this book was wonderful, it is still a bad book. The snippets I’ve been able to read without buying it are awful. The message is vague at best and easily misconstrued to the detriment of the age group it’s targeted at. It is self-published. Why? Because any publisher with half a brain wouldn’t publish this round-file worthy piece of junk. It’s elementary, in a bad way. To that end, no matter what the subject matter was, I still wouldn’t buy this for my child.
Writing children’s books is (native-New Yorker) Kramer’s second career. I have to assume that, since he’s self-publishing these books while living in Hawaii, he was actually good at his first career. So, my official commentary on Maggie Goes on a Diet is this: Do not buy this book. Do not visit Kramer’s website, Aloha Press, or even click through any ads on any sites displaying this book. Ignore it like the bargain-book-bin piece of junk it is. Kramer, if you feel strongly about literacy, children’s health, childhood development, etc. perhaps you should look into volunteering with an established group working in one of those areas. Please.
If you’re looking spend your time and energy on something book-related, check out these sites and invest yourself in something good (and let us now refrain from furthering the publicity for this guy and his lame book):
Jumpstart’s Read for the Record (coming up Oct. 6, 2011 – time to get ready!)
Reading is Fundamental
LitWorld
Shop Better World Books (donate books or sell/buy textbooks) to make a difference